Built in 1845 by Clement Jagger, a prosperous carriage-maker in Bath, Ohio, this Greek Revival-style home was relocated a short distance to Hale Farm in 1962. Today it is interpreted as the "Wheatfield Township" home and office of "Dr. William Tibbals" and his family.

The most frightening house at Hale by far is the Jagger house. This house itself hates. . . I hated to work in that house, even during the day. And whoever worked in there would just become hateful the entire day. If you stayed in the house for just a few minutes you just hated everything and everyone. People that worked that house together would be arguing constantly.