The historic Sanibel Lighthouse was built in 1884; it was one of the first lighthouses on the Gulf Coast. A request for a lighthouse had been active since 1878; however, the $50,000 needed to build the lighthouse was not granted until 1883. Within 3 months, the 98-foot, iron structure was complete. It was lit on August 20th, 1884, by the first lighthouse keeper, Dudley Richardson. The lighthouse ran on kerosene oil, which had to be carried up a 127-step spiral staircase by the lighthouse keeper. The lighthouse is located in Lighthouse Beach Park, which is a popular site for shelling, fishing, beach dwelling, and sunsets.

In addition to being famous for its history, the Sanibel Island Lighthouse, which was constructed in 1884, is also said to be haunted. Rumors circulate about a former lighthouse keeper's spirit, George Wendell, prowling the grounds of the lighthouse complex. Visitors and locals have experienced strange phenomena, including flickering lights, odd footsteps, and eerie apparitions. Many claim to have caught glimpses of George's ghostly figure, often described as a solemn presence watching over the waters. Whether these tales are rooted in reality or simply the product of vivid imaginations, they add an intriguing layer to the island's charm and draw paranormal enthusiasts from far and wide.